October 29, 2026

Part 2: Cipolla's zero criminal charges VS Fr. Zula's 130 counts

August 30th, 2026 was the tenth anniversary of the sudden & violent death of heart surgery patient & neuropathy sufferer, Anthony Cipolla.  He was also the victim of thoroughly fact-checked accusations  which turned out to be definitively proven lies.  
 
Examples of those lies are in this post, for familiarization purposes.  A series of them, in sufficient detail, comprises a number of other posts in the August & September 2026 archives of the Wuerl-of-Hurt site.  And of course, Cipolla is not the only subject/topic presented at this site.
  
 
 
Due to the unending attacks upon a deceased man unable to defend himself ... up front is the case used by Donald Wuerl as a diversionary tactic that created a smoke screen for Wuerl's undisputed abusive priests.  This same Cipolla Case was also presented to the public in a very false light.  
 
Then there was 2016, the year Cipolla died.
  
Ten years ago, the man formerly known as Father Anthony Cipolla was being traumatized by a defamatory three-part article written by a woman named Randy Engel.  He was being given ZERO rest & ZERO peace in 100% of his waking hours.  He then ran out of hours.
 
The pertinence to this is that traumatizing a heart patient to death involves what is known as the Eggshell Skull Rule.  It's also known as the Talem Qualem Rule.  People have been formally charged, convicted, and sentenced to penitentiaries for such deadly actions.

In the continuing saga of Donald Wuerl's well established hypocrisy, in letting himself be called "the bishop of zero tolerance," he was covering up for Richard Zula, despite Zula's well known violent reputation which earned for him the nickname, "Sade."   

When it came to Zula, as well as Wolk, Pucci, Zirwas, Huff, Burchianti, and John Hoehl, Donald Wuerl was no bishop of zero tolerance.  The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette very falsely claimed he was.  And of course, the subscribership of the Post-Gazette was so low that the Post-Gazette had to schedule the cessation of operations, for May 3rd, 2026, until an ill-advised non-profit group purchased it.

A Long Time a Lyin' about the same one tortured person 

As far as go the examples of the falsehoods which demonized Anthony Cipolla, [1] he was never arrested in his life, especially in 1978;  [2] Donald Wuerl's official "Just Cause" for defrocking Cipolla in the early 1990s, was NOT sexual abuse.  In fact, the 1995 Vatican Rehearing had nothing to do with Tim Bendig's or Diane Thompson's accusations against Cipolla.  

None the less, concerning Bendig, he tried to get Cipolla criminally indicted in two county jurisdictions.  Both attempts failed.  After all, Bendig alleged that he was molested by Cipolla, between the ages of 13 and 17, at the rectory of St. Canice Parish, when, in reality, during most of that time span, Cipolla was stationed 25 miles away, in New Brighton Pennsylvania.  

Cipolla was stationed in New Brighton, for about 3 to 3.5 years of the time span Bendig claimed was a time span of molestation at St. Canice.  During those 3+ years, Cipolla had no bedroom at St Canice Parish.

And remember, Bendig lied to me four times in a row, during the same one private conversation I had with him.  This occurred some time around the Year 2014, give or take a year.

The Vatican Case   

The 1995 Vatican Rehearing had nothing to do with Bendig's accusations or those which came through a Diane Thompson.  The rehearing dealt with the question, if whether or not Wuerl had the right to entirely remove Cipolla from the "clerical state," based solely upon the diagnosis of a Maryland clinic which stated, "Clinical Depression and Suicidal Tendencies."  

And remember, I was handed the box of documentation pertaining to that case and the Bendig lawsuit, etc.  Proof that Wuerl had no new evidence for even the filing of Wuerl's 1993 appeal, consisted in the request letter sent out by the Pgh Diocese, shortly before the appeal deadline.

That request letter was addressed to priests who were at one time stationed with Cipolla.  It was the diocese's way of hunting for any enlightening revelations about Cipolla, in any category of information or opinion.  Wuerl and the diocese were scrambling, looking for incriminating evidence against Cipolla, in order to get a previous Vatican Signatura ruling immediately suspended.  

And of course, Wuerl needed the original Vatican Signatura ruling suspended, because, if Wuerl were to have put Cipolla back into ministry in 1993, at least one Western Pennsylvania district attorney would have gotten out the proverbial white glove and scoured Wuerl's diocese with search warrant after search warrant after search warrant ... and even a grand jury.

https://www.donaldwuerl.com/2026/07/wuel-had-zero-evidence-against-cipolla.html

 

The 1995 Vatican Rehearing also sought to answer the question if Wuerl had the right to ignore the clean bill of mental health Cipolla received from a board-certified & licensed psychiatric facility in NYC, called St. Michael's.

 

Now, that which is pertinent here, in terms of the legality of Vatican procedure, is that Wuerl filed his appeal for a rehearing on March 21st, 1993.  The letter sent to specific Pittsburgh priests in search of dirt of Cipolla is dated 16 days after Wuerl stated that there "might" have been incorrect evidence in the first Cipolla Signatura hearing.  

An appeal dependent upon new evidence was filed without new evidence.  You could call this one of two things.  You could call this "a waiver" or you could call this "typical 20th Century Vatican Corruption" which got even worse after Ratzinger became pope, in the 21st Century.  Being that Wuerl didn't officially ask for a waiver, you could correctly guess that it was a matter of corruption ... or the use of an extreme loophole.

Of course, Ann Rodgers-Melnick of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette claimed that Wuerl's new evidence was a police report.  She lied.  The July 25th, 1978 Offense/Incident Report was NOT a Police Report.

An O/I Report is merely the beginning of things, in terms of investigation.  Technically speaking, they are "preliminary claims."  A Police Report is the conclusion of an investigation.  Then, when you want an arrest warrant issued to you, by a judge, you file a Police Affidavit which is the police officer's conclusion under oath.  That becomes the initiation of the legal process.  

If you are a D.A., you technically file "an information" which is equivalent to a grand jury indictment.  The bottom line is that, once again,  Ann Rodgers-Melnick told the People of Western Pennsylvania non-truths.  

There was no Police Report in the 1978 Cipolla Case.  Nor was there one in the Bendig Case.  Wuerl had no right to a 1995 rehearing, and it had nothing to do with molestation accusations.  It's already explained at the Wuerl-of-Hurt site, where the reading of the posts is free of charge ... pun intended.

Once again, for those who are exceptionally stubborn, concerning Bendig's accusations, keep in mind that Bendig expressly claimed that Cipolla molested him for 5 years at the St Canice rectory, when Bendig was between 13 and 17 years old ... between 1982 and 1986.  Bendig expressly said that Cipolla would take him up to his bedroom in the rectory and molest him there.

The big problem here is that Anthony Cipolla was stationed 25 miles away, at the McGuire Memorial Home, beginning in December of 1983.  Cipolla did NOT have a bedroom at the St Canice Parish during three of those years.  Observe:

 

Moreover, there was never any DNA evidence against Cipolla, in the 1978 case, as Randy Engel very falsely claimed.  In fact, the 1978 case lasted a grand total of 35 days, and in the 1970s, it took 49 to 59 to 69 days to get a DNA test result produced.  

There wasn't enough time for a DNA test result to have arrived in the 1978 Cipolla Case.  And there was no semen found on Tucker Thompson, in the first place.  The July 25th, 1978 O/I Report did NOT mention any appearance of semen anywhere on Tucker, and the same O/I Report stated that Tucker's medical condition, as was assessed at Allegheny General Hospital, was 'GOOD.'

The complete contradiction at the outset of 1978 accusations

In the July 25, 1978 O/I Report, Frank Labiaux was never mentioned as having claimed to have been molested, and the report stated that Tucker only claimed to have been molested twice.  

The first time Tucker claimed to have ever been molested was some time around the July 4th festivities of 1978 ... give or take a day or two.  

Now, Tucker claimed that he was molested while being tutored by Cipolla in a one-student first holy communion class ... in July.  The contradiction is this:  

Since when does a person hold a tutor session on the holidays? And and and and and, in the Catholic Church, during the 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s, first holy communion was traditionally in April, May, and June.

None the less, in late July of 1978, Diane Thompson said she had to pry out of Tucker that which Cipolla allegedly did to Tucker.  Well, such prying usually only occurs weeks, months, and even years after a molestation.  How did she get info out of Tucker almost immediately, on July 25th?

The Methodist Church LIE

Concerning the claim that young Frank Labiaux was so frustrated over having been allegedly molested that he vandalized the nearby African Methodist Church in 1977, it was one big lie.  This is because the two acts of vandalism upon that church made the news, and the two vandals who were caught and arrested DID NOT include Frank Labiaux.  

Plus, the date of the actual occurrence of the double vandalism differs drastically from the date Randy Engel reported.  The two acts of vandalism both occurred in November of 1978.  Diane Thompson and/or Frank Labiaux told Randy Engel that the vandalism of the African Methodist Church occurred in mid-1977.  This is already covered in another post.   

Diane Thompson and/or Frank Labiaux stole that news story and put Frank's face on it, to deceive people into thinking that something known in the area applied to Frank.  Well, it didn't.  Two older boys did the vandalizing a year and a half later than Frank and Diane claimed it to have occurred. 

Plus, Diane Thompson claimed that she had to exit Pittsburgh for Cleveland in September of 1978.  Well, how did she know of the November 1978 acts of vandalism, during a time when there was no internet ... unless if she were still in Pittsburgh, in November of 1978? 

In review, there was two and only two 

There were only two series of accusations leveled against Cipolla, and they were leveled nine years apart.  Each one was leveled by and/or through an individual who was desperate for money.  Each of these two persons asked entities of the Diocese of Pittsburgh for money and were then denied their requests.  They then leveled accusations against Cipolla.  

In fact, Bendig leveled accusations against nine other priests, in 1987.  Then, during his lawsuit deposition in the early 1990s, he was asked how he knew that the priests he mentioned were practicing sodomites. Bendig answered, "I heard it through the rumor mill.  Rumors."  Well, when Bendig mentioned this to the press, he made it sound as if he personally experienced each priest being a predator at the Pgh seminary.

There was the accuser mother of 1978 who asked for Cipolla's parish to get the St Vincent de Paul Society to pay her monthly apartment rent, and there was Tim Bendig who asked to be given severance money, as he left the Pittsburgh seminary from where he was expelled.  

In Bendig's case, Cipolla then told his Padre Pio Prayer Group attendees ... at the after-mass reception ... to stop sending money to Bendig at the Pittsburgh seminary, being that he was expelled from there.

In the Bendig case, Bendig told the Beaver County DA's office that he was molested by Anthony Cipolla for 5 consecutive years ... from the age of 13 to 17 ... at St Canice Parish, in Knoxville, PA.

Well, when Bendig was the age of 14 to 17, Anthony Cipolla was stationed at the McGuire Home in New Brighton, in Beaver County jurisdiction.  St. Canice Parish was/is in Allegheny County jurisdiction, within the 15210 zip code, and Cipolla was transferred when Bendig was 14 years old or so.

This is the first instance in the Bendig case, where it's "most probable" ... "almost certain" ... that Tim Bendig was fabricating a very false story.   Bendig lost track of his lies.

After all, if a person is not enduring "repressed memory," where the person forgets the entire scenario of having been molested, that person is going to easily tell anyone where he was molested, if he were truly molested there for five consecutive years.

 
Now remember, "rumor mill" is hearsay and not permitted in court ... unless the person alleged to have said or done something is deceased or otherwise unavailable to testify.  Moreover, the person who was claimed to have done or said something about which he is not available to confirm or deny with his own testimony is known as the declarant.
 
Moreover, Tim Bendig personally lied to me four times in a row.  Thus, my personal experience with Bendig is that he was definitely a liar ... a con artist.  

And of course, I cut off all communications with Bendig, because he would have lied about any meeting or conversation I would have had with him.  

This is why I also refused to ever talk to Diane Thompson and to ever write to Diane Thompson.  Plus, she is an annoying insult to any reasonable person's intelligence, anyway.  

October 28, 2026

Part I: Cipolla's 1978 accuser LIED about being forced to drop non-existent charges

At the outset of this tutorial, the block of information below has long since been needed to be posted, due to decades of defamatory newspaper reporting against an Anthony Cipolla whom the Post-Gazette would not allow to defend himself in print or through any Post-Gazette interview.

Amidst the unbridled demonization of Cipolla, Jesuit author, John Hardon ... whose cause for canonization is already underway ... firmly believed in the innocence of the same Anthony Cipolla.  Yet, the Post-Gazette declined to report on a famous author's thoughts on the subject.

It wasn't freedom of the press that the Post-Gazette was conveying.  It was mere propaganda which ever-so-coincidentally benefited Donald Wuerl:

Concerning this defamatory newspaper, it was scheduled for closure, on May 3rd, 2026.  In the past 20 years of operation, it reportedly lost $350 million in operating costs.

So, take note of the information below and absorb it into your memory bank.  It's the opposite of what Mrs Randy Engel claimed in her 2016 three-part article which ended up being posted by the Renew America site:

       

The sole surviving detective assigned to the 1978 Cipolla case, namely Warren Bud Droz, admitted to a Pennsylvania grand jury, during a 2016 Grand Jury Inquest, that he had no physical evidence against Anthony Cipolla in 1978.  For the record, his partner, Leo Marchetti, died in 2012 and was unable to testify, needless to say.

THEREFORE, Warren Bud Droz's general conclusion that 12 year old children never lie to police is, in itself, a repeatedly proven LIE.  Thus, Droz had no valid foundation upon which to have believed anything that came from the mouth of Frank Labiaux in 1978.  Furthermore, Labiaux did get caught being part of a decisive lie told to Randy Engel and then written into her 2016 defamatory account against Cipolla.
 
Then came the DNA LIE 
 
The DNA LIE asserted by Randy Engel, in a Renew America publication,  easily could have triggered a multi-million dollar defamation lawsuit.  The problem here is that those who had the Article III Standing with which to file a lawsuit were either dead or advanced in years.
 

The OHIO LIE of none other than Diane You-Know-Whom 

For the record, as was previously mentioned in another post, the most recent defamation against Cipolla was the claim that people in Ohio were coming out of the proverbial woodwork, accusing him of molestation, while filing lawsuits against him ... four and five years AFTER his August 2016 death, in 2020, 2021 or 2022.   Of course, this is a complete falsehood.

In the entire history of Ohio, from the first day when the first white man walked on its terrain, all the way to August 31, 2026, not a single person in Ohio or originally from Ohio ever accused Anthony Cipolla of molestation.  This was yet another Diane Thompson LIE. 

 All in all ... as is supported by evidentiary support ... the fact-checking of the entire Anthony Cipolla Case, which was the result of extensive work, showed that the Cipolla Case, as it was presented to the public, was one continuous string of falsehoods.  It was an absolute insult to the intelligence of any reasonable person who is even slightly familiar with American legal procedure.  

The 1990s, when cover-up artist Donald Wuerl artificially became a star 

The 1990s newspaper narration of Diane Thompson being coerced into signing a 1978 sheet of paper in Bob Colville's office shows how much of a liar she was and how much of a bunch of liars were the editors of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.  At the least, it shows how presumptive the editors were.

Of course, add to the Liar's List Ann Rodgers-Melnick, a person whose public dishonesty secured for her a management position at the Roman Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh, despite the fact that she was never a Catholic Church member in any of the six major liturgical rites of that Church.

This also showed how much of a team of liars Wuerl & his attorneys were, in not correcting the falsehoods being reported as fact.  After all, this is the lying newspaper whose people spent over a decade very falsely calling the blatantly manipulative and even vengeful Donald Wuerl the Bishop of Zero Tolerance ... as well as the Model of Zero Tolerance.  

Yet, Wuerl displayed much tolerance toward Wolk, Zula, Pucci, Zirwas, Hoehl, Burchianti, Huff, Castelucci and other priests of a criminal nature.  In as much, while the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette heralded Donald Wuerl as the heroic Model of Zero Tolerance, molester priests were on the Diocese of Pittsburgh payroll.  This included convicted felon priests who had already been indicted and convicted.  A case-in-point was Richard Zula.

The Bob Colville Coercion Tale proved that the Thompson Clan and the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette editors were clueless as to basic procedural law in the United States 

In review, for those of you who are exceptionally stubborn, exceptionally bigoted, and/or exceptionally brainwashed by either the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette or writer Randy Engel or any Wuerl-influenced entity: 

The entire narration of the August 1978 Bob Colville Coercion Tale was a harrowing one, where Diane Thompson claims that she was brought into Bob Colville's office and illegally detained there ... until she signed a sheet of paper that was needed "to drop the charges" filed against Anthony Cipolla.  

Yet, as of August 28th, 1978, Cipolla had neither been put in handcuffs nor put behind county jail bars, simply because no charges were filed against him.  The entire "filing of charges" tale was a deliberate lie.  Meanwhile, the "dropping the charges" tale was a much bigger lie.  This is because no civilian on Earth ever had the power to sign any sheet of paper that got criminal charges in America dismissed in any case.

In as much,  here is a re-Reality Check for you people out there who never studied law and who are still in denial that Randy Engel, Renew America, and others LIED about the 1978 Cipolla Case:

         

Now, the 1978 Cipolla Case was NOT a federal case.  It was a Pennsylvania Commonwealth case that never resulted in charges being filed.  Thus, a quick review of federal criminal procedure is necessary here.

It's known as Rule 48a, and it's reference goes back to a case known as the Rinaldi Case.  Very simply, the Supreme Court, years ago, surmised that Rule 48a was originally designed to PREVENT a powerful defendant from being able to use a corrupt prosecutor to oust a poor & powerless accuser from the court system through the dismissal of the case.  It was designed to prevent any rich & powerful defendant from bullying a poor & non-influential accuser/victim.

Rule 48a requires "LEAVE OF THE COURT" for a prosecutor to dismiss federal charges.  And of course, "leave of the court" means "permission by the judge."  This prevents a corrupt prosecutor from letting a defendant go free, while disregarding the true wishes of the accuser/victim.

That specific rule is in the APPENDIX of Title 18 of the United States Code.  The US Code is the encyclopedia "volumes" of all laws appearing in congressional acts, being that all such laws become "codified."  

Each federal volume is officially referred to as a Title.  There are 53 Titles in the USA Code.  Meanwhile, there are 67 volumes of State Law in the Pennsylvania Code.  And of course, these codes are congressional laws.

Moreover, federal law ALWAYS supersedes state law, when there is a conflict of law.  And and and and, a congressional law always supersedes a presidential or a gubernatorial executive order.

So, there was a countermeasure inserted into federal law that was designed to prevent an accuser without wealth & political influence from being ousted from the court system by a corrupt prosecutor, while the defendant goes free.  Not even in federal law does a civilian have the power to sign a sheet of paper which "unilaterally drops the charges."  Thus, a federal prosecutor can't "force" an accuser into "dropping charges." 

Very simply, no civilian anywhere in the United States has the power to "drop the charges" in any criminal case.  This included the Diane Thompson of 1978, especially concerning an Anthony Cipolla who was NOT charged for any crime in the same year of 1978.

This is because the power to drop criminal charges is solely reserved to the sovereign-governing-authority which is referred to as "the State."  This includes the federal governing authority in federal jurisdiction cases, being that the federal government is also regarded as "the State."  After all, the United States has an administrative authority called the Secretary of STATE.

Every criminal case in America begins with either "The State of Such-and-Such vs defendant-of-the-case or The Commonwealth of Such-and-Such vs defendant."  Even federal criminal cases begin with "the United States vs defendant-of-the-case."  

Therefore, only the court officers of the prosecuting State or the United States have the power to dismiss charges that have already been filed in the name of the prosecuting State or the United States.  

And of course, this means "dismiss the charges," "withdraw the charges," "drop the charges," and "Nolle Prosequi."  Each phrase means the same thing.  

Moreover, any other procedural matter concerning Anthony Cipolla would have occurred at the CLERK OF COURTS OFFICE, and not in the office of DA Bob Colville.

 

So, what did she do on August 28th ... 1978? 

Well, ladies & gentlemen, the only procedural thing that Diane Thompson could have done on Monday, August 28th, 1978 was "withdraw her private criminal complaint."

Now, a private criminal complaint is a petition to the "court of jurisdiction" to file charges.  It is NOT the act of filing charges.  

Then, there is the matter of withdrawing a private criminal complaint.  Firstly, if the DA acts upon the private criminal complaint and does file charges, then the complainant cannot file a withdrawal.  A complainant can only withdraw her criminal complaint IF neither the DA nor a presiding judge issued a warrant for the arrest of the accused.

This is because, as soon as criminal charges are filed anywhere in the United States, the case is put solely in the hands of the prosecutor and the judge.  

No civilian anywhere on Earth can "drop the charges" against any defendant anywhere in United States jurisdiction, in criminal law. NOT even Diane Thompson could have done this in Bob Colville's office, in 1978.

Procedural Review 

In order for a private citizen to withdraw his/her complaint, he/she, known as the COMPLAINANT, had to ...

... appear AT THE CLERK OF COURTS OFFICE in person, to get the paperwork done, and NOT in any county District Attorney's office.  This included Bob Colville's office, in 1978.  

Even if Diane Thompson filled out any necessary withdrawal forms in an assistant DA's office, she still had to go to the CLERK OF COURTS OFFICE IN PERSON, to make her paperwork official.  Thus, nothing became official in Bob Colville's office ... or in any assistant district attorney's office.
 

Even if the drop-the-charges saga had been a misinterpretation of Diane Thompson withdrawing a private criminal complaint:

 
A judge and a D.A. are independent of the will and wishes of all private citizens and can file criminal charges upon their own discretion.  This means that, if a government official found evidence that suggested Cipolla's guilt, then that official could have filed on Cipolla after August 28th, even into the Year 1979.  No one needed Diane Thompson's permission, for the filing of charges against Cipolla.  
 
That which was needed was evidence-against-Cipolla, and as the Late Bud Droz testified in 2018, there was no physical evidence against Cipolla in 1978.  Such a requirement is known as "the Burden of Proof."
 

Furthermore, Diane Thompson gave Randy Engel a narration of post-arrest activities which never occurred, such as the post-arrest prelim hearing scheduled for "Police Station #9."  This is because no prelim hearings were held at Police Station #9. 


 
  
In some jurisdictions, a judge requires a probable cause hearing to be concluded first, before accepting the complainant's private  citizen's complaint and then having it filed.   
 
The act of a judge ordering the arrest of an accused person is known as "issuing process."  Meeting the burden of proof is required.  Therefore, in such cases where a judge finds "no fair probability that any crime was committed and that the accused was likely involved," the case is dismissed without the need of any complainant signature.
 
Doubly therefore, it's possible that, on August 28th, 1978, Diane Thompson signed nothing.  In such a case, what she would have done, therefore, was ... "defaulted" and then proverbially disappeared.  
 
 
 
The rapid timing between the "alleged" July 25th molestation and the calling of police made the entire accusation look like a premeditated scheme. 

Another important feature of the Tuesday, July 25th, 1978, O/I Report is that, according to Diane Thompson & "Thomas 'Tucker' Thompson," Cipolla molested Tucker between 3:10 PM and 4:30 PM.  

Well, Diane Thompson literally called the police at 5:15 PM.  This means that she was supposedly able to "pry out of Tucker" deeply troubling information within 45 minutes to 2 hours after Tucker was allegedly molested ... and within one hour after Tucker got home.

The point here is that Diane Thompson claimed that she had to extract a secret from Tucker.  Well, in past cases throughout America, it would not be for weeks or months or even years that a molestation victim would finally reveal the incidents of his molestation to an adult.  Yet, Diane Thompson claimed to have "finally" extracted deeply hidden information within one to two hours after a molestation event.  

Such a thing would have broken some kind of speed record.  But, such a rapid time span makes the entire thing look like a premeditated con game, especially in that the accusations came shortly after Diane Thompson was denied her request to have Cipolla arrange for the St Vincent de Paul Society to pay her monthly apartment rent.  

As the past 45 years have illustrated, accusing a priest of molestation can be a very lucrative undertaking in the United States, especially for people who need apartment rent money.  

Diane Thompson finally got $250,00 for her harrowing tale that was easily disproved in as far as concerned the accusations involving a Tucker Thomas. After all, his July 25th medical condition was officially said to have been GOOD, by Allegheny General Hospital, thereby showing zero signs of him having been molested or assaulted in any form, on July 25th, 1978. 

It involved only her yet-to-be-investigated, starting-point accusations, AND NOT a police conclusion 

The accusations hand-printed exactly below the middle of the 1978 page below are merely the starting-point & the not-yet-verified accusations of Diane Thompson who spoke in the name of the nine-year-old boy who, on the sheet below, is identified as Thomas Thompson.  Those accusations ARE NOT the findings of the police.  

When that sheet was filled-out and signed, the detectives didn't even begin to investigate the accusations.  The only finding on that sheet of paper was the Allegheny General Hospital finding that, on July 25th, 1978, after an examination, Thomas Thompson's physical condition was GOOD.  Such a finding is the opposite of being found to be the victim of a physical crime.

  ...  ... All in all, on Monday, August 28th, 1978, Diane Thompson was not able to even to show to Judge Laffey that a violation had probably occurred on her son.  Thus, her attendance at an August 28th Probable Cause Hearing was a certain loss for Diane Thompson.  So, she had to make up a harrowing tale.  

She instead told the tale of corrupt government officials and more corrupt church officials sabotaging her case and forcing her to drop criminal charges that cannot be "dropped" by any civilian, in any case, anywhere in the United States.  

Her big lie was in her claim that Cipolla was found guilty beyond doubt, due to a DNA test result said to have been quickly produced by Allegheny General Hospital, during an era when the average DNA test result took an average of 52 days to produce ... and also during an era when DNA test results were usually produced by an NIH lab, and NOT by any hospital.

The general rule of the private citizen's criminal complaint 

When it comes a private citizen's criminal complaint, it is never a matter of you pressing charges.  If any person in America could file criminal charges, then there would be total chaos in the court system.  Con artists and vengeful people would be filing charges to the point of overloading the legal system and causing it to be unable to operate.

When neither judge nor prosecutor approved of a private citizen's criminal complaint, an Oversight Prosecution was possible, in years past ... but apparently not today.

If neither a DA nor a judge approved the private criminal complaint, it used to be that the "complainant" was left to do the prosecuting, himself/herself.  But, the civilian did the prosecuting under the watchful eye of an assistant DA.  Technically, such a thing is "an oversight prosecution," with the assistant DA doing the overseeing.

And of course, it has always been a rarity for a private citizen to prosecute a case in America.  Even at that, during such rare cases the civilian prosecutor still had no power to "drop the charges" during the transpiration of the case.  

Plus, such a thing appears to be mostly a thing of the past

Concerning judges and/or district attorneys accepting a private citizen's criminal complaint and then filing charges against the accused, it was during 1978, when 10% of the criminal cases in the USA were started by a private criminal complaint ... where the DA took-over the case and prosecuted the whole thing without the help of the private citizen complainant.

None the less, perceive what the Post-Gazette and Thompson ... in the Court of Public Opinion ... were accusing the 1978 DA's office of having done in her claim that Bob Colville forced her to sign a sheet of paper that "dropped the charges" ... that were never filed in the first place. 

 

This shows that Diane Thompson & the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette personnel ... in the 1990s & in the 2010s ... were nothing but a bunch of liars thinking that Pittsburghers are stupid enough to believe anything stated by the Post-Gazette, as if it were the Infallible Voice of God.  

Well, the Post-Gazette was only the Voice of Annoyance and it has been an Insult to the Intelligence of the Reasonable Pennsylvanian.  It's grand DECLINE in subscribership in the 2010s & 2020s proves this to be so.  

Plus, the Post Gazette management was not very kind to its employees.  Due to low subscriber numbers, the Post-Gazette could NOT afford to be kind to its employees. 

It's no wonder why the Post-Gazette underwent a decline in subscriber numbers so significant that its management planned to shut down operations by May 3rd of 2026.  Then, a certain non-profit organization purchased it.  Well, that non-profit organization purchased a severe liability.  If you're going to do that, you might as well hire a reckless driver to be your personal chauffeur.