October 31, 2026

That July 1978 sheet of hand-printing was NOT a police report NOR an arrest report

The medical findings conveyed on that sheet of paper ... by which Allegheny General Hospital found no signs of sexual assault having been committed on the nine-year-old "Thomas Thompson" ... exonerated Cipolla, in as far as concerned the accusations involving the nine-year-old Thomas Thompson.

The great lie of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette's Ann Rodgers-Melnick in 1993 & 1995 was her claim that the Vatican's high court centered its focus on sexual abuse accusations, in Anthony Cipolla Case.
 
The truth is that the 1995 Vatican rehearing of the Cipolla and Wuerl case did not involve molestation accusations at all, especially in light of the fact that Cipolla was NEVER indicted anywhere at any time for any type of indecent assault charge, ever.  
 
This furthermore means that Cipolla NEVER had to register as a sex offender anywhere on Earth.  Therefore, as far as went the claim that the Vatican tried Cipolla for sexual abuse, read here:

 This should make you aware that Tim Bendig LIED, when he told a certain reporter that the Vatican tried Cipolla for molesting him and found Cipolla guilty.  This also serves as added evidentiary support that reinforces the multiple claimants who, from personal experience, claim that Tim Bendig is nothing but a con artist liar.  Even yours truly learned of Tim Bendig's con artist dishonesty through personal interaction with Tim Bendig.  

Bendig was a smooth operator with his dishonesty.  He almost had me conned ... deceived ... joining his side of the debate.  However, I read the box of "Cipolla Case Documentation" that was handed to me, during a pre-arranged meeting, in an Italian restaurant, before business hours.  Because of this, I instantly caught Bendig in four lies.  If he would have stopped and not gone on, talking and talking, he would have won me over.

None the less, Bendig lied to me four times in a row, contradicting his previous lie each time in lying to me.  He gave me four different stories to the same one event which never occurred in the first place.  

Once again, if I hadn't previously read the contents in the box of Cipolla Documentation, Bendig would have had me completely conned. 

The objective of the Vatican's high court in 1993 & 1995 was to judge if whether or not Wuerl was justified in having officially removed Cipolla from priestly ministry, based solely on a Clinical Depression & Suicidal Tendencies diagnosis given to Cipolla by St Luke's Institute in Maryland.  
 
Wuerl's official grounds for laicizing Anthony Cipolla was Psychic Defect ... NOT "sexual abuse."  Ann Rodgers LIED.  Actually, she lied as a matter of habit when it came to rolling out the pro-Wuerl propaganda like a Hollywood red carpet.
 
That Vatican case was also tasked with answering if whether or not the clean bill of health Cipolla simultaneously received from the board-certified & licensed St. Michael's of NYC was evidence which Wuerl had to consider as valid & substantially weighted, in his final assessment on Cipolla.
 
In re: Vatican Procedure 
 
More specifically, that case was NOT officially titled, "Cipolla v Wuerl."  In fact, the 1993 hearing was only that of the high court hearing Cipolla's attorneys, with Wuerl's representatives being absent.  The 1995 "Vatican Re-hearing" was only that of Wuerl's lawyers speaking to the high court, with Cipolla's lawyers being absent.
 
The United States legal procedure is called the Adversarial System, and it differs from Vatican court legal procedure which is ... predictably enough ... called the Inquisitional System.  
 
In the inquisitional system, the judges are "inquiring minds."  They are inquisitive researchers, asking questions of the evidence-experts and the witnesses, as well as the canon law experts.  
 
In the USA system, the judge is the impartial monitor, and does not initiate actions.  The judge only judges the actions, accepting them or not, except when a bench trial is underway.  A bench trial is one where the judge is the jury. 
 
All in all, in the 1995 Vatican high court's re-hearing, no lawyer was there for Cipolla, in order to speak for Cipolla.  Likewise, in 1993, no lawyer was there at the same high court, in order to speak for Wuerl. 
 
1995 
  
It was falsely reported that, when Wuerl walked off of a jetliner at Rome's international airport in 1995, he was carrying a newly obtained piece of evidence.  The newly obtained piece of evidence was claimed to have been a "police report."  That was yet another media lie, for the benefit of Donald Wuerl's public image.   That sheet of paper was NOT a police report.  It was something decisively different. 

The July 25, 1978 sheet of paper containing hand-printed basic info at the top of it, and hand-printed damning accusations, starting at the middle of it, and also containing a medical exam result section, was ...

... an Offense/Incident Report, aka an O/I Report.   

Exactly at the center of it began nothing more than Diane Thompson's untested, yet-to-be-investigated, starting-point accusations, spoken in the name of the nine year old "Thomas Thompson" who was also known as Tucker Thompson.  

That report was NOT the police conclusion.  It was NOT the "police findings."  Diane Thompson spent years deceiving people into believing that her entry-level, starting-point accusations were the official findings of the police.  

That which is absolutely essential for any American journalist or historian to understand about an Offense/Incident Report is this:

 

An Offense/Incident Report contains NO CONCLUSIONS of law enforcement officials, being that it constitutes only the beginning of a case which may go nowhere or which may lead to criminal charges & a conviction.
 
The O/I Report, when a civilian accuser is involved, is only the accusations of one or more civilians, followed by a possible medical examination of those persons alleged to have been victimized as a result of the crime being reported.  Of course, the results of a medical exam can either confirm or dispel accusations set forth in an Offense/Incident Report.
 
In the July 25th, 1978 Offense/Incident Report, the medical exam section basically exonerated Cipolla, as far as went the nine year old, Thomas Thompson, aka Tucker Thompson.  There was absolutely no indication that any type of physical crime had been committed on young Tucker's body, on July 25th, 1978. 
 
Now remember, I spoke at length with the man who signed that July 25, 1978 I/O Report.  He was one of the two uniformed police officers who went to the Thompson residence, to take Diane Thompson's statement.  And of course, he was the man whom I located through the Pittsburgh Steeler organization.  His name was and is Mark Ninehouser, a true gentleman, at least while speaking to me.
 
Well, he definitively said to me that all he did was jot down what Diane Thompson said, and then he transposed his notes on to an Offense/Incident Report form.  
 
Apparently, she spoke for young Tucker, being that Mark only spoke of Diane Thompson, when explaining to me his July 25th visit to her domicile.  Tucker did not come up in the conversation.  It was understood by me that Diane Thompson was proverbially running the whole show, when it came to giving the police a statement on behalf of young Tucker.
 
All in all, Mark Ninehouser did NOT play Sherlock Holmes.  He neither played Columbo NOR Adrian Monk NOR any other TV detective.  Mark did NOT bring out a white glove or a magnifying glass.  He did NOT concur with the accusations leveled against Cipolla.  He simply took dictation notes.  Period.  
 
After that one visit to Diane Thompson's domicile, Mark Ninehouser had nothing further to do with the case.  He was finished with it, after he hand-printed his notes on to an I/O form and signed it.  His signature appears in the middle of a bottom-area line, followed by the number 46.  Forty-six was his badge number he told me. 
 
The Contradictions of Diane Thompson's ... and Tucker's ... Story 
 
As far as goes the damning accusations in the July 1978 O/I Report, the great asininity in it ... in that it instantly loses credibility ... goes as follows: 
 
  1] Anthony Cipolla was presumed to have been fully clothed, while he was accused of having one finger inside Tucker's rear side, while allegedly playing proctologist.  Meanwhile, Cipolla was alleged by Diane Thompson and/or Tucker as having had his other hand on Tucker's private front section ... while Tucker was unclothed.   
 
2] Well, Diane Thompson told writer Randy Engel that, on July 25th, at the hospital, semen was found on Tucker, followed by a quickly produced DNA test result which proved that the semen belonged to Cipolla.  And of course, there was no DNA involved in the 1978 Cipolla Case.  After all, the average amount of waiting time for official DNA results in 1978 was 52 days.  Plus, the DNA testing did NOT occur in hospitals.  It occurred in NIH labs.  This DNA claim was yet another easily provable LIE of the woman whose name was Diane Thompson in 1978.
 
 
3a] The contradiction is that, if Cipolla still had his clothes on, while  molesting Tucker, then how did semen go through Cipolla's clothes onto Tucker's body?  And if Tucker were not touching Cipolla in any fashion, then how did an excited emission of semen and other bodily fluids go from Cipolla to Tucker's body, in the first place?  
 
3b]  According to the July 1978 statement of the Thompson Household, Tucker did NOT allegedly have his hand on Cipolla's body, especially on Cipolla's private sector.  Yet, Cipolla was somehow excited enough to leave a souvenir of male body fluid on Tucker's body, while Cipolla had his clothes on. 
 
Very simply, a molester adult wants to proverbially "get his rocks off."  Putting a finger in a proctologist's main area of examination does not get a molester's rocks off.  It doesn't make the molester's little rocket ship "down there" blast off.   And of course, using a hand on a child's private anatomical sector doesn't result in the molester blasting off and leaving behind a souvenir of bodily fluid, either. 
 
That entire scenario reported to police on July 25th, 1978 was impossible.  Plus, the form of molestation described in the July 25th 1978 O/I report was not the way child molesters molested children.  Usually, it was the child's hand and the adult's private anatomical section hat were put to use.  
 
A repeated example of this was in the case of molester extraordinaire, Marcial Maciel Degollado.  He was the founder of a religious order who, when on his deathbed, refused to receive the last rites of the Catholic Church.  
 
In years prior, Maciel had his students put their hands in the service of Maciel's private anatomical sector, under the guise that it was medical therapy for Maciel.  Maciel even told the students that he received an indult ... a dispensation ... a permission slip ... from the pope to have it done to him as such.  
 
Thus, Diane Thompson got the story backwards.  Her fictional account should have had Tucker's hand on Cipolla's private anatomical part.  The awkward narrative of July 25th 1978 was one reason why no judge was willing to issue a warrant for Cipolla's arrest.
 
So, in order to hide the fact that Diane Thompson fabricated an asinine tale, in my private citizen's personal opinion of a public figure ... which is protected under NY Times v Sullivan, 376 us 254 (1964) ... she made up the story of DNA testing, followed by Cipolla getting arrested, and finally followed by Bob Colville forcing Diane Thompson to sign a sheet of paper that would "drop the charges" against Cipolla ... 
 
... when the fact is that, IF Cipolla had been indicted, Colville could have dismissed the charges on his own discretion, without any signature from Diane Thompson or anyone else, anu yime before judicial procedings began.  But of course, Cipolla was NEVER CHARGED, in the first place.

However, Diane Thompson then thought up even more asinine tales, in order to make you feel sorry for her, while being outraged at Cipolla.  One example was the claim that there was a 1965 special forces near-death training accident experienced by her then-husband which occurred at a Spartanburg military base, in South Carolina.  
 
And of course, this makes the man sound like an all-American, flag waving hero, while making Cipolla look like the sneaky, diabolical, invader taking advantage of an American hero who couldn't defend his children.  
 
Well, that Spartanburg military base was closed down eighteen years prior, in 1947.  Thus, there was no way in which Diane Thompson's then-husband was there, doing Vietnam Prep Training.  After all, Vietnam special forces training was done in a jungle environment.  Spartanburg is in north-central South Carolina, near the North Carolina border.  And of course, North Carolina is no jungle. 
 
In Defining a Police Report 
 
As far as goes the legal instrument known as the police report, it's usually the written account of one of the police officers who responded to a crime in progress or a crime recently completed.  It's usually the writing of an officer who became a witness to the crime.  Many police reports were written by an officer who was there, at the scene of the crime, making the arrest.
 
On other occasions, a police report occasionally involved an officer successfully obtaining evidence or corroborative witnesses ... or a confession ... which incriminated the accused person mentioned in the report.  
 
Whereas the Offense/Incident Report only contains initial, unproven, starting point accusations which have not yet been tested as to their validity, a police report, on the other hand, contains conclusions known as "findings."
 
Next comes the Police Affidavit which additionally involves a police officer submitting his findings under oath, claiming them to be true.
 
For all intentions & purposes of the Anthony Cipolla Case, the July 25th, 1978 Offense/Incident Report involved no cross-examination of Diane Thompson's & Tucker Thompson's statement.  There was simply the statement jotted-down on a form, in hand-printing.  There was NO JURY VERDICT involved.    There was no DNA lab test result involved.
 
Plus, all the consonants and vowels in a 1978 O/I report were in capital letters, except for the letter "i," so as to not confuse the letter "i" with the number 1.
 
The police did NOT concur with the damning accusations of 1978, because they were only Diane Thompson's side of the story printed on that one sheet of paper, along with Allegheny General's medical findings which did NOT substantiate a single accusation made by Diane and/or Tucker Thompson.  The statement was 12 lines long.  It's at the bottom of this post.
 
Allegheny General 
 
Now, the Allegheny General medical findings were pivotal, because, during the examination of nine year old "Thomas Thompson," Allegheny General found NOTHING which indicated that a crime was committed on young Tucker Thompson's body, on July 25th, 1978.   
 
This is pertinent, because young "Thomas Thompson" was alleged to have been molested a few hours prior.  Thus, evidence should have been fresh.  No physical evidence was reported by Allegheny General, at all.  There were no medical indications that Tucker had been molested by anyone or anything.  

More importantly, there was no report from Allegheny General that there was any kind of lubricant anywhere on or near the 9 year old child's private anatomical area.  That claim only came from the Thompson Household, with no medical professional concurring that it ever occurred.  That accusation was unfounded.  Period.
 
Diane Thompson's Defamation against Bob Colville
   
That which was frightening to a person unfamiliar with American legal procedure was Diane Thompson's description of the alleged corruption of D.A. Bob Colville.  She claimed that Colville had her in his office, against her will, forcing her to sign a sheet of paper which would forever "drop the charges" and which were never filed in the first place.  
 
Also remember that no civilian on on Planet Earth had the power to "drop the charges" in any criminal case, in any American clerk of courts office or in any D.A.'s office.  

So, the July 25th, 1978 O/I Report was NOT the police agreeing with Diane Thompson, and it certainly was NOT the police unilaterally announcing what happened on July 25th, 1978.  It was only Diane Thompson and/or young Tucker making accusations not yet tested for honesty & validity.  At that point, the accusations were still needed to be tested, to see if whether the accusations were substantial or unfounded.
 
Only Twice 
 
On the July 25th, 1978 report, Tucker ... or Diane Thompson spoken in the name of Tucker ... claimed that Cipolla allegedly molested Tucker only twice.  That's it.  That's all.  That is mentioned on the O/I report.  
 
This, alone, takes the proverbial air out of many online writers who insinuated that Cipolla allegedly molested Tucker for 4, 8, or 12 consecutive months, week after week or month after month.  
 
Due to the weakness of the Tucker accusations, Diane Thompson needed to bring 12 year old Frank Labiaux into the accusation scene.  She needed him to spice things up.  At present, he needs to be cross-examined in the Court of Public Opinion, being that he was already was caught in the lie about the vandalism at the African Methodist Church.  This means that he can't be trusted at all, especially since he took half of the $250,000 shelled-out to Diane Thompson in 2019 or 2020 or so.
 
Diane Thompson and Frank Labiaux claimed that Frank vandalized a nearby African Methodist church in 1977, with the help of one accomplice, due to the frustration of having allegedly been molested.  The reality is that the two acts of vandalism occurred in November 1978.   Yet, Diane Thompson claimed that she left Pittsburgh for Cleveland in September of 1978.  So, how did she know of the November 1978 Pittsburgh news, when there was no internet and no smart phones?
 
In fact, the slitting of the tires in the church parking lot occurred exactly on November 17th of that year.  This is much much later than the date very falsely alleged by Diane Thompson and Frank Labiaux as having been the date of the church's vandalism.
 
For the record, The two individuals who actually committed the vandalism were hoodlums a couple years older than Frank.   The bottom line is that Frank Labiaux has proven to us that he can't be trusted.
 
Now remember.  I spoke with the actual July 25th officer at length.  In contrast, the author of the outrageously non-factual and defamatory 2016 Renew America article did NOT speak with him at all.  Mrs Randy Engel didn't even know how to find him.  Basically, Randy Engel knew how to find unsubstantiated gossip & calumny.  But, she had a severe difficulty in finding the truth.
  
Allegheny General's Official Medical Examination Finding 
 
Keep in mind that the medical exam which Allegheny General performed on the nine year old Thomas (Tucker) Thompson stated nothing more than the physical condition of young Thomas was "GOOD," in the July 1978 I/O Report.  The comment section was a blank space, meaning that nothing bad happened to Tucker on that day.
 
As a reminder, concerning Diane Thompson's claim to Randy Engel that a late July 1978 DNA TEST at Allegheny General Hospital quickly identified semen as belonging to Anthony Cipolla:
 
I've previously stated six to eight to ten times that, in 1978, DNA test results had a waiting period of an average of 52 days ... and the testing was done at NIH labs, and NOT in hospitals.  
 
Meanwhile, the 1978 Cipolla Case only lasted 35 days.  There was not the time for a DNA test result to arrive in the Cipolla Case.  Thus, claiming that there was DNA evidence in the case was an egregious lie.   
 
Plus, as was admitted by former Detective Warren Bud Droz in his 2018 grand jury testimony, there was no physical evidence in the 1978 Cipolla Case to present to any judge or D.A., at all.  
 
They simply didn't molest in that way 
 
Moreover, have you studied the accounts of molestation?  Uhhhm, there was usually much much more than just a spot of lubricant found on or near the child's private anatomical region.  You would find a lot more than a spot ... and and and, on occasion, noticeable blood.  
 
In addition, don't you think that a pedophile would insert something other than a mere finger into a child's backside, for a thrill, even though it would definitely cause the child to bleed?  
 
In my private citizen's personal opinion of Diane Thompson, as far as concerns July 1978, she stated that Cipolla inserted a finger, instead of a more private male anatomical part, because there was no blood on Tucker and no evidence that anything relatively large penetrated him.  So, she picked a much thinner body part, for her story.  And according to Allegheny General, it was just a story.
 
The bottom line ... the thesis statement ... is that Diane Thompson spent years deceiving people into believing that her July 25th, 1978 list of untested & unproven starting-point accusations were the official conclusions of the police.  And of course, Randy Engel fell for it, along with Randy Engel's "good good New Jersey friend" with whom I spoke for hours at a time and found her to be in need of a very good psychiatrist.   She was pushy.  She was over-domineering.  She was a control freak.
 
On another post or two, I have detailed some of my experience of listening to that New Jersey woman talk for consecutive hours, even into 5 in the morning.  
 
The only conclusion of one of the detectives assigned to the case was that no 12 year child anywhere would ever lie to a police officer.  And of course, court records throughout America prove this general assertion to be a lie.  A number of preteens, aged 11, 12, and 13 lied to the police and lied in a courtroom.   
 
In fact, a few of those witnesses were coached by police to lie on record and then to lie in a courtroom.  Yes, there were youths who lied for the police.  Thus, there were youths who lied to the police with the police knowing it.  I've outlined examples in another post or two. 
 
  

October 30, 2026

Part 1: Cipolla's zero criminal charges VS Fr. Zula's 130 counts

 

Wuerl's treatment of Cipolla, in comparison to Richard Zula & Leo Burchianti 

Even after Richard Zula's conviction, Wuerl gave him a monthly stipend ... a monthly check.  Anthony Cipolla had no criminal record.  Yet, he received nothing from Wuerl, despite the fact that Wuerl was the one who defrocked Cipolla without having done so for a criminal reason.  

Cipolla was NEVER a convicted molester in secular or church court.  Cipolla was never even indicted.  But, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, Randy Engel, and others made sound as if he did.  The truth is the Cipolla NEVER had to register as a sex offender.

And of course, Wuerl additionally revenged Cipolla for going over Wuerl's proverbial head, to the Vatican.  This is the action of a childish and immature brat who should never have been given any position of power.  The message from Wuerl was that you don't dare challenge Wuerl without paying for it immeasurably.   

But, the true message is that Wuerl got away with abusing his power and destroying lives ... even during the Fathert James Torquato Retaliations ... where some laymen got caught in the middle of it all and could have gotten very physically injured.  

Things were heated in that case, because Wuerl let Torquato do what Torquato wanted to do, to escalate the incitement of violence against his accuser and his accuser's whistle blower advocate.  

Torquato even got a person who rents things at North Park to accuse Torquato's accuser of having stolen a bike.  So, Torquato did try to have someone frame his accuser for a crime he never committed.

In contrast, the Leo Burchianti who molested eight youths got to live at St John Vianney's House, for the rest of his life.  Cipolla didn't get to do so, despite his heart condition & neuropathy, as well as his diabetes.

In fact, Cipolla successfully passed a Pennsylvania State Police security clearance background check in 2014.  I ordered it from my construction trailer office desk and even paid for it myself.  And of course, it was something that was provided at a very affordable price.  Any Pennsylvania peasant could have afforded such a thing. 
 
Below is Anthony Cipolla's July 24th, 2014 Pennsylvania State Police Criminal Record Check.  It officially states, "The Pennsylvania State Police do hereby certify that: Cipolla, Anthony Joseph ... Date of Birth: 08/29/1943 ... Social Security xxx-xx-xxxx, etc," ====> 
 
"*** HAS NO CRIMINAL RECORD IN PENNSYLVANIA, BASED ON A CHECK BASED ON THE ABOVE IDENTIFIERS - REFER TO CONTROL #R12542432 ***"
 
Concerning the 1978 Case, according to the Baltimore Sun & Social Law Library

Plus, a concurrence from another source is posted below
 

 Yet, she assured her readers that Cipolla was mentally deranged, even though the Fr John Hardon she honored as a great teacher of Catholicism defended Cipolla's character to the core of his existence.

In 2016, Randy Engel assured us with great confidence that the evidence of Anthony Cipolla being a serial molester was blatant.  She stated that the evidence existed in the fact that Cipolla was "moved around" a lot of times, during his first five years as an active priest.  He was given multiple parish assignments in as many years.  

Engel forgot about the PRIEST SHORTAGE of the late 1970s, when priests were in a pea & shell shuffle game. 

According to Engel, this five parish assignment is unheard-of, and is the tell-tale sign of a molester.  According to reality, however, the multiple parish assignments given to a newly ordained DIOCESAN priest was something quite common in the late 1970s, according to the expert sources quoted below.  None the less, Engel erroneously concluded that:

Of course, Randy Engel was making it look as if Anthony Cipolla kept getting caught molesting youth after youth, followed by him being assigned to a different parish here and a different parish there, as a cover-up.  This is why multi-million dollar defamation lawsuits exist.  After all, my expert sources stated the opposite of what Engel stated in her 2016 article, concerning newly ordained DIOCESAN priests and their parish assignments.   

Now for the major hypocrisy of Randy Engel, in her damning of Cipolla, in his parish assignment record
 
Randy stated that the Pgh Diocesan spokesman, Fr Ron Lengwin, asserted that the average priest's first assignment is about five years in duration.  If a priest's first assignment endured lesser than five years, then there was something wrong with the priest, in terms of discipline and emotional stability.   And of course, my multiple expert sources stated the opposite.
 
None the less, according to Randy Engel, if you are a priest whose first parish assignment was five years long, then you are a good man who was never accused of molestation.  Therefore, you never had to be moved to different parishes, to cover-up your habit of molestation.
 
Newsflash, folks:  Fr Richard Zula's first parish assignment lasted 5 years.  Yet, he was a monster, once charged with 130 criminal counts.  In fact, Zula had a parish assignment that was 4 and a half years long, as well as a parish assignment 4 fours long.  Thus, Richard Zula, by means of his parish assignment record, appeared to be a stable man.  He was anything but that.  Randy Engel, in her assessment about a priest's first five years, was wrong. 
 

Father Edward Huff's parish assignment record is that of a non-molester, according to Randy Engel & Ron Lengwin.  But, Huff was a convicted molester, proving Engel & Lengwin to be WRONG.

Fr Huff's first three parish assignments were five years each.  According to Engel & Lengwin, this is surely the sign of a stable non-molester.  But, Huff was quite the molester, proving that Randy Engel & Fr Ron Lengwin did NOT know what they were talking-about. 

Next is Fr John Wellinger.  His parish assignment record makes him look acceptable to Randy Engel and Fr Ron Lengwin.  In fact, his first parish assignment was nine years long.  That would make him look really really stable in the estimation of Randy Engel.  But, he was anything but stable.  And Randy Engel was anything but correct.

And then there was Father William O'Malley who was accused of molesting his first youth in 1980, as well as multiple youths somewhere around 1991.  Then, in 1997, someone accused him of having been a molester even in 1978.  
 
He was then sent to rehab, and then he was reinstated by Wuerl in 1998, in a limited role, only.  O'Malley was placed on a glorified version of "administrative leave."  He was appointed to be a Canonical Consultant, but he was not allowed to dress as a priest or perform public mass.  
 
Yet, after 1998, between April 2002 and January 2006, six more males came forth, claiming that they were molested by O'Malley in years past.  Three of them claimed to have been molested in the mid-1970s, during his second parish assignment.
 
Well, in O'Malley's first five years of priesthood, he was assigned to only one parish.  In fact, the next two assignments were 3 1/2 years each, followed by a parish where he was assigned for almost 7 years.  
 
According to Randy Engel and Fr. Ron Lengwin, O'Malley's parish assignment record was that of a stable and well adjusted non-molester who could be trusted.  Well, O'Malley was anything but well adjusted.  

So, once again, Randy Engel is proven to be completely wrong in her proclamation, and she was malicious in her public defamation of an Anthony Cipolla who actually never was arrested and who had no DNA tests performed on any molecular substance which would have physically come from his body.     
All in all, there exist many more examples of molester priests whose parish assignment records would be declared the sign of a good & holy man, by Randy Engel & Fr Ron Lengwin.  
 
And remember, Ron Lengwin spent many years being Donald Wuerl's propagandist, even stating that there should only be one voice of Catholicism in America and that voice should be Donald Wuerl.   Therefore, Ronald Paul Lengwin was to Donald Wuerl what Paul Joseph Goebbels was to Adolph Hitler.  It's simply that Ron Lengwin was much taller than Goebbels.

Self-proclaimed Psychiatry Expert, Randy Engel 

In the same defamatory 2016 article, Randy Engel concluded that Anthony Cipolla most probably was at least borderline schizophrenic or borderline psychotic.

Big Question: Ladies & gentlemen, what is deadly wrong with Randy Engel's derogatory conclusion about Cipolla's state of mental health?

ANS: Cipolla was analyzed by TWO board-certified and licensed psychiatric facilities, and both facilities OFFICIALLY did NOT diagnose Cipolla as being Schizophrenic or Psychotic.  

In fact, the licensed NYC psychiatric facility gave Anthony Cipolla a clean bill of mental health, through & though.  Yet,  Randy Engel, in her elitist arrogance, placed herself above two mental institutions and their board-certified & licensed professionals.  

Quite frankly, Randy Engel and her "good good New Jersey friend" are the ones who need to be in a psychiatric institute.  Literally.

Engel's claim of unusualness 

In her claiming that it was "unusual" for a newly ordained diocesan priest to have been frequently shifted from parish to parish in the 1970s, Engel LIED.  It was and is very common for a newly ordained DIOCESAN priest to be shifted-around, simply for the sake of gaining experience, according to the published experts. Then came the matter of the late 1970s priest shortage.  

Newly ordained priests of a religious order are a different issue, being that they are limited to only the parishes run by their religious order, as well as their religious order's affiliated Catholic schools.  So, their assignments were far more limited than that of a diocesan priest, for the most part.  So, you expect a religious order priest to spend longer times in a parish assignment ... or else in mission work.

Diocesan priests were in a different set of circumstances, with much wider boundaries.  By the way, a diocesan priest is also known as a "secular priest."

Observe the reality of a newly ordained diocesan priest ... even in the 1970s ... according to the Archdiocese of D.C, the Denver Catholic, the Jersey Catholic, EWTN, and other sources: 

 
 
Did you ever wonder what contributed to the priest shortage of the late 1970s?  Well, the answer is that it was caused by the final phase of the Vietnam War, in March of 1973, and then at the end of the same war, in April of 1975:

 
ABOVE: Get into reality and take note that the 'TYPICAL NUMBER OF MOVES" made by "NEWLY ORDAINED PRIESTS" were & are usually "UP TO 5 IN 5 YEARS." 
 
Now, Anthony Cipolla became a NEWLY ORDAINED DIOCESAN PRIEST on May 27th, 1972.  Thus, it was expected for him to have been  assigned to as many as five parishes in his first five years, during a priest shortage that basically begin in March of 1973.  

MOREOVER, instead of getting arrested in 1972 or 1973 or 1974, he received COMMENDATIONS which were known as "a recognition" & "an expression of appreciation" ... even from POLICE!!!!
 
AND REMEMBER, the 2018 Pennsylvania Grand Jury had the power to scour through church archives and documents involving any accusations against any priest.  The record has it that Cipolla was NOT a serial molester being moved from parish to parish, in order to cover-up any molestation activities.  There was found no record of sexual abuse accusations against him in his first five years of ministry.
 
Once again, to assure you that the defamatory, self-righteous, & holier-than-art-thou Randy Engel was 100% WRONG in her assessment of Cipolla's first five years of ministry take note:  
 
During that time span, there was ZERO ACCUSATIONS of any kind of sexual abuse leveled against Anthony Cipolla, thereby justifying the plaques of gratitude given to Cipolla during that time span ... even by police.  
 
Plus, during the 2018 PA Grand Jury Inquest, ZERO files of sexual abuse accusations against Cipolla were found and/or presented to the grand jury.  This would mean that zero existed.  
 
That is to say, there apparently was no such secretly hidden molestation file of any kind on Cipolla, showing that Randy Engel is nothing but a defamer who loves calumny and who sees herself as the stereotypical "self-righteous, holier-than-art-thou church lady," when, in reality, she's just a gossipy hag.  
 
However, according to Randy Engel and her "good good New Jersey friend," the police were engaged in the cover-up of a molester priest, thereby making the police accomplices to the crime of molestation.  To reasonable people, however, the police were showing gratitude to a 1970s priest who found a way to keep kids "off the streets" and "out of trouble."  
 
Q:  So, were the police the accomplices of a molester or is Randy Engel the stereotypical & predictable gossipy hag of absolutely worthless value, clinging to her defamation? 

The 2018 Pennsylvania Grand Jury Inquest blew the doors on the Diocese of Pittsburgh wide open.  This included the Pittsburgh diocesan archives.  

If Cipolla were a serial molester, a secret archive file somewhere would have emerged, at the hands of a Pennsylvania State constable, which would have recorded far more accusations than the 1978 ones and those of a Tim Bendig who contradicted himself at the outset, when speaking to a Beaver County PA assistant DA.  

It would have then been entered into the record, if there were more accusers than that of the Bendig and the Thompson party.  That is to say, if he were the molester Randy Engel conjectured him to have been, then two, four, or six more accusers would have emerged, and they would have given testimony to the 2018 PA Grand Jury.  

No new accuser came forth.  

That, alone, proved Engel's defamatory article of 2016 to be a multi-million dollar defamation lawsuit waiting to be filed ... if there is someone out there still alive who has the constitutionally required Article III Standing, in the defamation hurled at Cipolla and which was spread throughout a large spectrum of humanity.  

Cipolla was never charged.  Zula was charged with 130 counts.

Richard Zula received a monthly stipend ... a monthly financial check or a monthly direct deposit ... from the Diocese of Pittsburgh, by order of Donald Wuerl, even after he was convicted of sexual abuse.  Cipolla received nothing from Wuerl, except massive doses of defamation, through Wuerl's surrogates.

And of course, the Richard Zula who received a monthly check from Wuerl was even found to have been in the possession of child pornography.  Yet, Cipolla was the one made out to be Wuerl's greatest monster, by the media and the internet.
 
So, for the record, Cipolla was NEVER found with any child pornography.  Richard Zula was. 
 

Concerning Cipolla's assignments, I do know that there was one specific pastor Cipolla could not stand.  This is because, he specifically told me.  So, Cipolla requested a transfer and got it.  But, Randy Engel insinuated that each parish assignment equaled one molestation accusation each.  

No, Engel simply succumbed to the influence of her pushy and emotionally disturbed "good good New Jersey friend" who wanted Cipolla gone forever.   Engel did NOT think things out.  She trusted her very pushy and hate-filled friend who did leave the Catholic Church ... which was ironic for Catholic-Doctrine-Supporter, Randy Engel.  Randy was basically a groupie following a New Jersey cult leader, at least in 2016.  

That New Jersey woman freaked out when Cipolla tried to get a home-schooling job as some kind of religion teacher ... in New Jersey.  I personally thought that this was the stupidest thing Cipolla ever did, and in the end it would come to cost him everything.  This is because that New Jersey woman wanted Cipolla out of the picture, proverbially & literally.   

None the less, when Cipolla was being interviewed for that job, he was NOT required to register as a sex offender,  being that he was NEVER even indicted for any type of indecent assault offense.  Thus, he was legally FREE-TO-GO.  It was Wuerl, Bendig, Thompson, and Ann Rodgers-Melnick spreading the tale of a monster devoted to Padre Pio ... not the police ... not any D.A.'s offense, and not any attorney general's office. 

That New Jersey woman wanted Cipolla dead, and she got what she wanted.  I call it voluntary manslaughter or negligent homicide or homicide by fright.  Remember, I talked to that New Jersey woman repeatedly, for consecutive hours at a time, and I can assure you that she wanted Anthony Cipolla dead ... literally.

None the less, the New Jersey woman didn't know that Anthony Cipolla:

1] ... was NEVER arrested ... even in 1978 ... but was rather defamed by a single mom who claimed that DNA evidence was taken from young Tucker's clothes and was positively matched to Cipolla in a hospital lab within one, two, or three days time, when the reality is that, in 1978, DNA matches took more than 7 weeks to complete ... with the testing thereof never occurring in hospitals ... but rather, occurring at NIH labs, in 1978. 

None the less, Cipolla was ... 

2] ... officially cleared by TWO DA offices who found that Tim Bendig's accusations against Cipolla were unfounded.  Now, the assessment of Bendig's accusations was limited to the specific testimony of Tim Bendig himself, unaltered & unedited.  There was zero physical evidence and no corroborating witnesses, at all.  

BTW, the two counties were I) Allegheny County where sits Pittsburgh and II) Beaver County, the home of 1] the former largest push button railroad in the World,  2] the world's first atomic power station,  3] a number of steel mills,  and 4] renowned athletes such as ~Heisman Award Winner Tony Dorsett, ~Super Bowl coach, Mike Ditka, ~Super Bowl QB Joe Namath,  ~NFL Hall of Fame inductee, Jimbo Covert, etc, etc, etc.

None the less, the list of four people in the center of the Beaver County DA case report below are all PEOPLE IN AUTHORITY ... or adults in influence, and not juvenile sex groupies or under-aged frequenters of the McGuire Home.  

In re:  Randy Engel didn't comprehend county jurisdiction 

More importantly, Randy Engel alleged that the Beaver County D.A.'s office was run by frauds, in that the March 17, 1989 report stated that Bendig was not a minor at the time "of the alleged offense."  Engel pointed out that Bendig claimed that he was molested for five years at St Canice Parish, between the ages of 13 to 17, and that the Beaver County DA should have taken this into account.  The years involved in the accusation were 1982 to 1986.

Well, St Canice Parish was/is located in THE ALLEGHENY COUNTY JURISDICTION.  The Beaver County D.A.'s office could only research allegations said to have occurred in Beaver County Jurisdiction.

More importantly, Bendig's accusation of five consecutive years of having been molested at St. Canice's parish rectory is easily disproved.  Cipolla moved out of the St Canice rectory, in December of 1983.  He was stationed at the McGuire Home, in New Brighton, PA in 1984, 1985, 1986, and in years further.

Being that Cipolla had no bedroom at St Canice Parish in 1984, 1985, 1986, and longer, there is no way in which Cipolla molested Bendig at St Canice Parish in 1984, 1985, and 1986.

In addition, Anthony Cipolla  ... 

3]  ... NEVER had to register as a sex offender, being that he was never even arrested for a sex offense, in the first place.  He was NOT arrested in 1978, as Randy Engel falsely claimed, and he was never arraigned or summoned to a hearing at Police Station #9, as Randy Engel claimed.  The writer of that 2016 article obviously knew nothing about American or Pennsylvania legal procedures.

In continuing, Cipolla also ... 

4] ... through his attorney, namely my former neighbor John Alan Conte ... 

... had dozens of character witnesses lined-up to testify at the Tim Bendig lawsuit trial which Wuerl made sure would never happen.  Wuerl simply gave Tim an out of court settlement shortly before the trial date.

And concerning this, Diane Thompson emerged for Attn Douglas Yauger, to be a witness in the Bendig lawsuit.  Wuerl definitely knew this.  

Well, Wuerl gave Bendig a six-figure out-of-court settlement.  If Wuerl believed that Diane Thompson were credible and honest, then why did Wuerl not give Thompson a form of settlement money of some sort?  Or did Wuerl allow money to reach Diane Thompson from under the proverbial table?  From behind the scene, perhaps?

No matter what, no public notice of Wuerl giving any kind of compensation to Diane Thompson was made, meaning that Wuerl did NOT publicly acknowledge that he found Diane Thompson to be credible.

Moreover, Cipolla ... 

5] ... was only accused by a Diane Thompson who was proven to be an outright wall-to-wall liar, and who was hard-up for apartment rent money during the time in 1978 when she accused Cipolla. 

And of course, Cipolla ... 

 6]  ... had no one accuse him of molestation ... outside of two financially desperate persons, namely Tim Bendig and the financially desperate Diane Thompson.

7]  Plus, in the thirteen years since I was first handed the box of documents pertaining to the Cipolla Case, not a single person ever contacted me, to tell me that Cipolla molested him or anyone else.

8]  The 1993 Vatican Case had nothing to do with Tim Bendig's or Diane Thompson's accusations.  

9] Moreover, Randy Engel's New Jersey friend refused to accept that  Diane Thompson was repeatedly caught lying.  And it was Diane Thompson who, after sending me emails which proved that she knew I existed, publicly stated that I didn't exist, but rather was Anthony Cipolla in disquise, operating this site under my name which Diane Thompson claimed was a fictional name.  

None the less, Cipolla's fatal error was walking into that home-schooling interview, under the guise of a priest-with-faculties and not as a suspended priest forbidden to present himself as a priest.  That was stupid of him.  Yet, Wuerl purposely put Cipolla in a state of desperation.  Wuerl manipulated circumstances.  Wuerl incited things by playing puppeteer.

None the less, at the time Cipolla had NOT been indicted for any type of indecent assault of sexual abuse.  Plus, Cipolla did NOT have to register as a sex offender.  Wuerl defrocked him on the grounds of PSYCHIC DEFECT, due to the Clinical Depression & Suicidal Tendencies he received from St Luke's Institute, in Maryland.  

None the less, Cipolla was completely cut off by Wuerl, even though Wolk, Zula, Pucci, and Leo Burchianti, as well as Huff & Zirwas, etc, were NOT cut off.  None the less, Cipolla needed money.  His reputation was ruined in Western Pennsylvania.  So, he went to Jersey, for work, and he actually asked a priest for the home-schooling job.  This means that the priest should have interviewed Cipolla.  But, the priest told the New Jersey woman to interview Cipolla, instead.

As far as goes work experience for Cipolla, it was limited to managing youth groups and prayer groups.  He needed to take with him the docs which proved that he was repeatedly CLEARED by LAW ENFORCEMENT and was never arrested in 1978.  

And and and, the 2018 PA Grand Jury Inquest showed that there were no other persons who ever accused Cipolla of anything ill.  There was no secret archive file of undisclosed accusers in Cipolla's case.

Cipolla also needed to dress as a layman.  Even at that, no home schooler would have hired him as a layman, unless that home schooler knew him for decades.  Cipolla still had people who believed in him, and concluded that Bendig was just a liar.  This included Jesuit author, Fr. John Hardon.

Cipolla Only Attempted this Once 

Most importantly, applying for a youth group chaplain type of a job was only attempted by Anthony Cipolla once.  If he would have kept trying, then that would have been the sure sign of a molester, on the hunt for children.  But, Cipolla didn't keep doing so.  If Cipolla had kept doing that, I would have called the police on him, myself.

And remember, I saw the whole 2016 article long before the November 30th, 2016 publishing of it, done by Renew America.  In fact, Randy Engel ... on a few occasions ... asked me to publish writings of her ... on my Marian website.  

And I spoke extensively to her "good good New Jersey friend,"  time after time, hour after hour.  Therefore, I am NOT a stranger showing up with an opinion.  I'm a long-term witness.  

Below are Cipolla's "pastoral assignments."
 
And remember, his personal interest was in prayer group & youth group chaplaincy, as opposed to parish life.  He was more into the liturgical ... and even ritualistic ... aspect of the Faith than shepherding parishioners.  Cipolla saw each youth as a possible recruit for the seminary ... or even the priesthood.   
 
Below:  Anthony Cipolla's Assignment Record